Monday, January 30, 2012

Towers and Bell Towers in the Movies

The other night, J and one of his long-time friends were watching the first Batman movie (1989) at our house. I didn't watch the movie with them, but I could hear their commentary from the next room. During the scene when Batman and the Joker have their final showdown in Gotham Cathedral (see above), K commented something like, "I wonder how other shows there are that have scenes with towers. It seems like there are a lot."

I thought this was an interesting comment, and I've been thinking about it lately. I can think of lots of movies that include tower scenes (often as part of the film climax), bell towers, and tower/bell tower imagery. When K made his passing remark, I immediately thought of Hitchcock's movie Vertigo (1958, see below), which culminates in a bell tower scene (see here and here).


And what about the clock tower scene in Back to the Future? ("Save the clock tower, save the clock tower!") As a kid, I also remember feeling anxious during the clock tower scene (in Big Ben) of The Great Mouse Detective (see below).


Side note: Interestingly, towers aren't always the location for climaxes, but their imagery is often incorporated into films. Big Ben is probably the best example. Tonight I came across this blog post which is a compilation of films in which Big Ben makes a cameo appears in the movies.

So here's my question: Why the obsession in film with towers, bell towers, and clock towers? What makes this setting so appropriate for the climax in a story? Is it because the height (climax) of the plot is visually emphasized through the height of the tower? Or, in a less metaphorical way, is it because of the physical height that is involved (to make the acrophobic in the audience nervous)? Or perhaps because towers usually only have one entrance/escape route (to make the agoraphobic in the audience nervous?) Or maybe the threat of lightning striking the tall structure? Or does it have something to do with what clocks and bells represent (i.e. the passing of time, the death knell, etc.). Perhaps towers embody all of these things, and I've answered my own question?

What do others think? Are there other reasons why towers are appropriate for climax scenes? And what other movies (or books!) do you know that include "showdown scenes" or climaxes located in towers? At present, the closest book scene I can think of is the "Lightning Struck Tower" chapter in Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, the scene in which Snape kills Dumbledore. There is also a scene in the film made from the book, too.

Oh, there also is a great rooftop scene described at the end of Jane Eyre, after the insane Mrs. Rochester set the house on fire. But that's not a tower scene. I just felt like writing about it. Interestingly, though, Mrs. Rochester is locked away in the attic in the actual novel, but the Masterpiece Theatre film version elected to place the crazy woman in the North Tower.1 Perhaps the director felt that towers better embody mystery and doom?

What is the earliest example of a "tower showdown scene" can you think of? The historian in me wants to trace a historical trajectory for this trend. Could Hitchcock have been a trendsetter for this type of scene with Vertigo, at least when it comes to film? It seems like there must be earlier examples, though!

1 Since I mentioned the attic in Jane Eyre, I thought I should mention that a few years ago a secret cell was discovered at Norton Conyers, the 16th century home thought to be the the location for Bronte's "Thornfield Hall." This has nothing to do with towers, obviously, but I think it's interesting.

6 comments:

M said...

My friend Creighton just suggested a few more scenes, which tie into the tower theme, even if not completely perfectly. But the idea of height is there. I'm quoting him directly in the first example, because "paternal bomb" is an awesome description.

1) "The end of The Empire Strikes Back where Darth Vader drops the paternal bomb on Luke Skywalker as he hangs from a ledge over Cloud City."

2) "Lord of the Rings," when Frodo and Smeagol wrestle for the ring above Mt. Doom

3) The famous Mt. Rushmore scene in Hitchcock's "North by Northwest"

The House That Lars Built said...

my first thought was Jane Eyre, but you got it. I'll keep thinking...

joolee said...

Makes me think of Shanghai Noon...super silly movie, i know. :) The first Sherlock Holmes with Robert Downey Jr. ends in a high scaffolding scene. Love those Sherlock movies!

The end of one of my fave childhood books, Redwall by Brian Jacques, ends on a bell tower scene too.

M said...

Someone else mentioned "Shanghai Noon" and "Sherlock Holmes" to me too, joolee! I haven't seen either of those shows.

These are some of the other film titles that I received from people who read this post, and I few more of my own. (Just so you know, I haven't seen a few of these films - I'm just trusting those who mentioned them to me!)

- The first "Die Hard" movie
- Hugo
-Disney's Robin Hood
- King Kong
- Towering Inferno
- The Dark Knight (was this tower scene a reference to the tower showdown in the first Batman movie?)
- The Hunchback of Notre Dame
- Matrix (fight going up the elevator to the tower)
- The Princess Bride (the sword fight between Inigo Montoya and the Dread Pirate Roberts is not exactly on a tower, but the ruins are really tall).

Someone also mentioned that the Twin Towers and 9/11 is a postmodern version of the "tower scenes" in films. I think this is a really good point. I wonder if there have been more or less "showdown scenes" with towers since 9/11. Perhaps towers now are something to "close to home" to be included in many films today?

BB said...

To riff on the 9/11 comment, I think you're probably right that the tower scene motif has diminished since 2001. Reminds me of a very moving montage I saw --- can't remember where --- where they strung together hundreds of clips from movies and television with the twin towers in the background. An elegy of sorts.

Another for your list: the matrix.

meg said...

You've started my wheels turning--I'll see if I can think of anything I can add to the list. I'm also curious about early tower scenes. I would be surprised if Hitchcock was the first to do clock tower scenes, but not surprised if he made them iconic.
I think 'King Kong' is an excellent point, though slightly different than the rest...